Yankees GM Brian Cashman insists team is not ‘analytically driven,’ paints small analytics staff as positive

After lacking the playoffs for the primary time since 2016 and placing up their worst regular-season profitable proportion since 1992, the New York Yankees are answering many questions in this day and age. That’s particularly the case for the reason that relative depths of 2023 did not result in significant adjustments within the entrance place of business or the dugout. 

No doubt, long-time common supervisor Brian Cashman is conscious about all of the criticisms directed at each nook of the group in this day and age, and the disappointment could have proven a little bit right through a scrum with journalists on the ongoing common managers conferences in Arizona. At factor was once whether or not the Yankees as a company are too analytically orientated. Here are Cashman’s now and then pointed remarks on that topic: 

To push towards the speculation — actual or imagined — that the Yankees are too invested in analytics, Cashman said: 

• The Yankees have the smallest analytics division some of the 5 groups of the American League East. 
• The Yankees have the most important professional scouting division amongst those self same 5 groups. 

The ordinary use of the phrase “bullshit” suggests this is very a lot a sore and drained topic for Cashman, and is the reason why he is in essence maintaining up the modest dimension of the Yankees’ analytics division as a excellent factor. The glaring rejoinder is that, given the Yankees’ huge assets, they will have to not have the smallest division of any sort amongst their divisional friends. 

The fact, after all, is that during 2023 all groups perform beneath some mix of analytics and conventional scouting. Some tilt extra towards one facet of the opposite, however each (completely suitable) faculties of idea tell each player-personnel resolution that each team makes in this day and age. Cashman, despite the fact that, would love everybody to grasp which approach the Yankees lean. 

However the Yankees arrive at their choices, how the ones choices determine in 2024 would possibly play a determinative position in whether or not or not Cashman is again maintaining courtroom on behalf of the Yankees subsequent offseason.