New You can now hear to Insurance Journal articles!
Some Florida insurers might really feel like they didn’t rating a house run with the current property insurance coverage reform measures signed into regulation in May. But they might quickly see a pleasant umpire on the state Supreme Court, doubtless to write some important attraction selections for years to come.
The Florida Supreme Court Judicial Nominating Commission, chaired by Fred Karlinsky, typically described as one in every of the powerhouse insurance coverage protection and regulatory attorneys in the state, this week submitted to the governor the names of 5 state-court judges and one training lawyer.
All have sturdy conservative bona fides, and three of the judges have written a number of opinions which can be thought-about to be pro-insurer in property and auto insurance coverage instances. Gov. Ron DeSantis will select one in every of the jurists to exchange retiring Justice Alan Lawson, giving the governor 4 of his personal appointees to the seven-member excessive court docket.
The odds-on favourite for Lawson’s spot seems to be Palm Beach Circuit Judge Renatha Francis, whom DeSantis nominated to the excessive court docket in 2020. At the time, Francis didn’t have at the least 10 years as a member of the Florida Bar, as required by the state structure. Now, she does. She could be the solely black justice on the court docket.
“I would very surprised if Francis did not get picked,” stated Robert Jarvis, a professor at Nova Southeastern University’s faculty of regulation. “Francis is an avowed conservative (she’s a member of the Federalist Society), and her few reported decisions are all strongly pro-insurer.”
Her selections embody Progressive American Insurance vs. Silverland Medical Center, written in 2019 whereas she was a circuit decide in Miami-Dade County. The opinion overturned a county court docket decide and located that Progressive didn’t owe private harm safety protection to the assignee, as a result of the proprietor of the car had by no means registered the automotive so as to get hold of the no-fault insurance coverage protection.
The medical heart had argued that the car had been parked most of the time, awaiting resale, and was not required to be registered.
“Taken all together, the legislative mandate is clear and unambiguous: motor vehicles driven on the roads of this state must be registered, and have security (PIP coverage), and such security must be continuously maintained throughout the registration period; failure to maintain such security is an absolute bar to entitlement to PIP benefits to a person injured in a motor vehicle accident – including benefits that may have otherwise been available under another person’s policy,” the opinion reads.
Silverland’s attraction was denied by the 3rd District Court of Appeal.
Francis concurred in one other 2019 choice that present in favor of State Farm Insurance in an vehicle accident case, noting that the insurer had proven that the medical heart’s costs may very well be thought-about unreasonably excessive.
The decide didn’t at all times see issues the insurer’s means, nonetheless. In 2019’s United Automobile Insurance vs. Preferred Health, one other PIP case, the majority of the circuit judges reversed the county court docket and located in favor of the insurer. The problem concerned the {qualifications} of the insurer’s doctor witness. Francis dissented, arguing that Preferred Health had correctly objected to the physician’s testimony.
Two different nominees, Judge Robert Long and Judge Adam Tannenbaum, each of the 1st District Court of Appeal, even have penned quite a few pro-insurer selections lately, in accordance to Jarvis and Florida attorneys who’re aware of the selections.
In DSK Group and Zurich American vs. Jorge Hernandez, for instance, Tannenbaum in April wrote the majority opinion in a staff’ compensation case. The appellate court docket narrowed the “going and coming” rule a bit and located that an electrician who was concerned in an accident on his means to the worksite was not due advantages, though he was carrying work provides at the time.
Steven Silberberg vs. Palm Beach County School Board and York Risk Services was one other comp case. Tannenbaum wrote {that a} instructor was not due compensation after his leg fell asleep, whereas sitting, and he fell when he tried to get up. The court docket famous that the harm didn’t are available in the course and scope of employment since sitting was a standard exercise – out and in of the office.
In Robles vs. United Automobile Insurance, Tannenbaum wrote that the insured was not due lawyer charges in a profitable attraction of a trial court docket’s order that transferred the venue.
“A close reading of that statute reveals that it does not authorize an appellate court to make such an award at the conclusion of an interlocutory appeal,” the decide wrote. Fees might be awarded solely after a judgment, he famous.
In Walls vs. Southern Owners Insurance, in 2021, Judge Long wrote in the appeals court docket choice {that a} volunteer employee killed in a automotive accident was coated solely by her private auto coverage, not the higher-limit coverage held by the group she was working for.
Also in 2021, Long wrote the opinion in State Farm Insurance vs. Nordin, a householders insurance coverage case. The court docket reversed a trial decide, discovering that State Farm had a proper to appraisal of the property though it had participated in litigation on the declare.
“Nothing in the record establishes that State Farm knowingly waived or engaged in conduct that implies it knowingly waived its right to appraisal,” Long wrote. “To the contrary, the record reflects deliberate action to evaluate the nature of the claims and then invoke appraisal at the first reasonable opportunity.”
Karlinsky, the chairman of the judicial nominating fee, instructed a Florida authorized news website this week that the six nominees represented “a diverse selection of highly-qualified jurists and practitioners with keen legal minds, who are committed to upholding Florida law and the U.S. Constitution.”
Topics
Carriers
Florida
Numbers