Texas’ safe haven law allows parents to give up newborns, but few do

Sign up for The Brief, our each day publication that retains readers up to velocity on essentially the most important Texas news.

Patsy Summey spent greater than a decade with a nonprofit offering training about Texas’ safe haven law. She distributed indicators, gave displays, helped with public service bulletins and chilly emailed hearth stations. The lifelong educator wished to unfold the phrase: If folks had been trying to find a means to safely and legally relinquish their new child infants, there’s a law to assist them.

“Some, because they don’t know about it, they don’t realize, ‘I can go in the hospital and have this baby, leave and not take the baby with me.’ They can do that,” Summey stated.

The thought behind Texas’ safe haven law is straightforward. Any guardian can deliver their child who’s lower than 60 days outdated to a fireplace station, hospital or EMS station and hand it over, no questions requested. If the infant is unhurt, parents face no felony expenses and the Department of Family and Protective Services takes custody.

Texas handed the law in 1999 below Gov. George W. Bush. Since then, each different state has adopted go well with. Lawmakers envisioned the law as an answer to a spate of baby abandonments in Houston within the ’90s. The law’s proponents felt that if one child could possibly be saved, it was price it.

But the measure lacked funding — proponents didn’t assume the invoice may go with a price ticket connected — so third-party advocates tried to unfold the phrase with PSAs and indicators. Promotion of safe havens relied on the goodwill of volunteers like Summey, who’s a retired trainer, and her group, known as Baby Moses Dallas.

The U.S. Supreme Court cited safe haven legal guidelines when it overturned Roe v. Wade. In his majority opinion discovering that there’s no constitutional proper to an abortion, Justice Samuel Alito talked about that every one states have safe haven legal guidelines, “which generally allow women to drop off babies anonymously.” During the Supreme Court’s oral arguments for the case final yr, Justice Amy Coney Barrett questioned why safe haven legal guidelines don’t care for “the burdens of parenting.”

But in Texas the law is never utilized.

Just 172 infants have been relinquished below the safe haven law since 2009, in accordance to knowledge from the Department of Family and Protective Services. Twenty-one infants had been surrendered below the law in 2020 — essentially the most in a single yr throughout that point span. Seven infants have been relinquished thus far this yr.

For comparability, there have been more than 50,000 abortions in Texas final yr and the state had virtually 370,000 live births in 2020.

Experts contend that the safe haven law isn’t used or recognized effectively sufficient to be a enough different to abortion. And as a result of it allows parents to relinquish their newborns anonymously, the consultants say, it’s troublesome to collect knowledge on why parents make this selection. They additionally say it’s not clear that the choice will likely be utilized extra in a post-Roe world.

“[The justices] seem to think that the existence of safe haven laws means that abortion can be outlawed with really no harm to women as a class, which I find very weird,” stated Jessica R. Pliley, a historical past professor at Texas State University who research ladies, genders and sexuality. “It’s a very strange argument, because, first of all, safe haven laws in Texas … there’s really just been not that many [newborns] surrendered or relinquished.”

In the Dobbs v. Jackson determination, justices’ majority opinion talked about anti-abortion advocates’ perception that “a woman who puts her newborn up for adoption today has little reason to fear that the baby will not find a suitable home.”

But that’s not clear in Texas, the place relinquished infants enter the care of the state’s Department of Family and Protective Services. That company is below federal monitoring after it was discovered to be routinely violating the constitutional rights of foster children, and has gone from “bad to worse” in recent times. Independent experts describe the system as “a disjointed and dangerous … where harm to children is at times overlooked, ignored or forgotten.”

Abortion rights advocates say the safe haven argument ignores the concept that 9 months of being pregnant can have life altering bodily, emotional, monetary {and professional} impacts, even when the mom offers up the infant ultimately.

“The idea that safe haven laws can be a solution to kind of the trials and tribulations that women who are seeking abortion space is actually disingenuous,” Pliley stated, “particularly when we think about the women who most need access to reproductive health care and to abortion services.”

Alito cited different arguments that “modern developments” — similar to medical health insurance or authorities help overlaying the price of childbirth, maternity go away insurance policies and legal guidelines towards being pregnant discrimination — present different choices or protections for pregnant folks.

But folks of colour have been almost certainly to entry abortion care, make up the vast majority of people who find themselves poor or low earnings, and lack entry to these sources, experts recently told the Tribune. Texas has the highest rate of uninsured ladies of reproductive age within the nation. The state has one of many highest maternal mortality charges within the nation, an investigation by USA Today discovered, and Black women are disproportionately affected.

Anti-abortion advocates acknowledge these points of their feedback after the ruling.

“Now the pro-life movement can expend even greater resources toward providing compassionate alternatives to abortion for women with unplanned pregnancies,” the Texas Alliance for Life stated in a press release. “Our goal continues to be to build a society where abortion is unthinkable, and women with unplanned pregnancies take full advantage of the vast resources available to them.”

But Gretchen Sisson, a sociologist at Advancing New Standards in Reproductive Health, a analysis program on the University of California San Francisco, stated she’s not sure that there will likely be a major enhance in safe haven utilization now that Roe v. Wade is overturned.

“When you talk about numbers that small,” she stated, “you could double them in a year, and it could just be coincidental.”

Laury Oaks, a feminist research professor on the University of California, Santa Barbara, stated she additionally doesn’t consider safe haven relinquishments in Texas are going to dramatically enhance as soon as abortions are formally outlawed.

“I think that those who are in the know already know about safe havens, and they’re not seeming to use safe havens to a vast degree,” Oaks stated. “I guess that part of my thinking about why safe havens aren’t going to dramatically jump is because other options, like legal, open adoption, are also going to continue to be options.”

Summey’s group, Baby Moses Dallas — named after the biblical story of Moses’ adoption after his mom left him in a basket within the River Nile — was established in 2004 with greater than a dozen volunteers. That quantity dwindled till Summey was certainly one of a handful of helpers left to unfold the phrase concerning the safe haven law in Dallas.

In 2016, the group determined it was time to relinquish their nonprofit standing, partly as a result of they lacked the formal construction wanted to perform, she stated. Although the group isn’t a nonprofit anymore, she and one other volunteer nonetheless make themselves accessible to reply to inquiries concerning the safe haven law.

She’s involved that even with Roe v. Wade overturned, the Texas Legislature isn’t going to set up extra assist for the law — whether or not via funding, training or each.

“I would hope that it would be used more,” Summey stated. “If a person who’s pregnant doesn’t know about the availability of that law, you know, then it won’t be used.”

Join us Sept. 22-24 in particular person in downtown Austin for The Texas Tribune Festival and expertise 100+ dialog occasions that includes massive names you already know and others it’s best to from the worlds of politics, public coverage, the media and tech — all curated by The Texas Tribune’s award-winning journalists. Buy tickets.