Texas may face “substantial fines” over its troubled foster care system

Sign up for The Brief, our each day publication that retains readers on top of things on essentially the most important Texas news.

U.S. District Judge Janis Jack stated Monday she plans to levy “substantial fines” in opposition to Texas for failing to conform along with her orders to repair its troubled foster care system.

Jack stated she’d announce at a later time a contempt listening to with a jury to think about sanctions. The state has already been sanctioned twice for violating the decide’s orders.

“I’m looking at substantial fines for contempt enough that you need to know you’re entitled to a jury trial,” Jack stated. “I think the public would like to know in a jury trial about these goings-on.”

Jack stated she was trying to sanction Texas specifically over the excessive charge of youngsters who’re sexually victimized or revictimized in foster care and the state’s failure in a number of areas, together with its incapability to correctly punish or shut down unsafe youngster care placement amenities; to report incidents through which a toddler is made unsafe; and to acquire approval earlier than putting youngsters in amenities on “heightened monitoring,” a probationary standing that requires the state to extra intently scrutinize a facility’s operations and put it on an enchancment plan.

Jack expressed renewed frustration with Texas’ lack of compliance with fixes she has ordered as a part of an 11-year lawsuit in opposition to the state’s foster care system.

“Those are just a few things I’m looking at for contempt but this has gone on far enough, long enough, without any remedial action by me. And every time I meet with you all, especially DFPS, it’s: ‘We’re looking at that, we recognize there’s a problem, it’s going to change,’” she stated. “Now, we’re going to look into fines and apparently, from what I’ve read, Texas has significant money to pay fines.”

In 2019, Jack fined Texas $50,000 a day and threatened to impose better fines however in the end ended them after three days.

Jack stated the Texas Department of Family and Protective Services is failing to correctly curb unsafe practices in amenities as a result of the company has issued citations solely to infractors and shies away from doling out stronger sanctions. State-licensed amenities are additionally failing to correctly report cases of abuse or neglect to DFPS regardless of “horrible things happening in these facilities,” she stated.

Jack stated one occasion through which DFPS didn’t cite a person for neglect was when a 5-year-old foster youngster drowned at a pool get together whereas the foster mum or dad was not watching them. DFPS officers stated in the course of the listening to the foster mum or dad wasn’t cited for neglect as a result of she was within the yard persistently and since it was an accident.

“Is that the dumbest thing you can ever imagine?” Jack stated. “The child drowned in a pool in the middle of a party, and you didn’t find neglectful supervision?”

Jack additionally referenced the case of a boy who claimed he was abused in a facility the place DFPS had positioned him and ran away. According to the courtroom screens’ report, his caretakers positioned him at his faculty however couldn’t get him to return with them; after trying to choose him up twice, they left him there. Hours later, the boy was struck by a automobile after squatting on the highway to allegedly are likely to an injured canine, the courtroom screens’ report stated.

He instructed a faculty regulation enforcement officer he didn’t wish to return to the ability he was positioned in as a result of he obtained “beaten up.”

1 / 4 of youngsters that DFPS recognized as victims of sexual abuse had been victimized or revictimized after coming into foster care, based on court-appointed screens who act as watchdogs over the system.

“That is not an acceptable figure,” Jack stated. “I don’t know what is an acceptable one but 25% is not.”

Throughout the listening to, Jack repeatedly expressed frustration as a result of DFPS officers couldn’t instantly present her with case specifics when she requested them, main her to ask if that they had learn the courtroom monitor’s experiences that had been supplied to them days in the past. State officers stated sure.

The decide referenced an incident in January on the Bastrop-based shelter The Refuge, the place a employees member allegedly solicited and bought nude photos of two women within the facility’s care. The incident finally led authorities to close down the 50-acre ranch whereas they conduct an investigation.

The accused employees member was beforehand fired from a state juvenile facility for having inappropriate relationships with youngsters in her care however was nonetheless employed at The Refuge. Shelter officers say they didn’t find out about her previous infractions; they by no means verified her employment on the juvenile facility.

Jack referred to as on the state’s youngster welfare officers to give you a system to stop related conditions from arising and to determine a method to receive information from the Texas Juvenile Justice Department on caretakers who’ve been discovered liable for abuse or neglect.

Ahead of the listening to, The Refuge filed two amicus briefs detailing their facet of the story however Jack struck them from the report. During the listening to, she reduce off The Refuge’s lawyer from interjecting, saying that The Refuge just isn’t a celebration within the 11-year case in opposition to the state.

The subsequent common courtroom listening to on this case is scheduled for December.

Join us Sept. 22-24 in particular person in downtown Austin for The Texas Tribune Festival and expertise 100+ dialog occasions that includes large names you understand and others you must from the worlds of politics, public coverage, the media and tech — all curated by The Texas Tribune’s award-winning journalists. Buy tickets.