Sunset Commission says PUC, which oversees Texas power grid, needs more money

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s every day publication that retains readers up to the mark on probably the most important Texas news.

The Public Utility Commission needs more state funding to make sure that Texas’ electrical grid doesn’t fail once more because it did in the course of the devastating 2021 winter storm, the Texas Sunset Advisory Commission mentioned Wednesday.

The fee, which often opinions state businesses and recommends potential enhancements or abolishment to the state Legislature, voted Wednesday to counsel that legislators improve the PUC’s funding and staffing.

“Chief among PUC’s needs is additional resources, specifically for the agency to independently analyze electric industry data and support its regulation of water and wastewater utilities,” Sunset undertaking supervisor Emily Johnson informed commissioners at a listening to in December.

The Sunset overview didn’t take a look at how ready Texas’ electrical utilities are for excessive climate or how the grid is operated. The Electric Reliability Council of Texas, a nonprofit that manages the grid and is overseen by the PUC, usually had the sources it wanted, in response to the report.

The fee additionally voted Wednesday to provide the PUC till May to develop a regular for what a dependable electrical grid would seem like. And they voted to advocate that legislators require the PUC to permit public testimony at its conferences on agenda objects. The company at the moment permits public remark solely on non-agenda objects.

The PUC has lacked sufficient sources for more than a decade and struggled to retain institutional information, in response to the Sunset workers report. Then legislators gave the company considerably more work after the near-collapse of the state’s electrical grid in February 2021, when days of freezing climate brought about system failures that left thousands and thousands of Texans with out power or warmth and tons of of individuals died.

The beleaguered company, which had round 200 full-time staff on the finish of final yr and likewise regulates the telecommunications trade, was given accountability to manage water and wastewater utilities in 2013. The Sunset workers report says the PUC didn’t obtain applicable funding when its mission was expanded.

PUC confronted “considerable challenges’” due to its small dimension, the report mentioned, “including a lack of needed expertise, cumbersome regulatory processes that can drive up costs to consumers, and a general inability to be more strategic and proactive, particularly in communications and data management.”

Johnson, the Sunset undertaking supervisor, mentioned in December that fee workers was “surprised to see PUC only has about 200 staff to not only regulate three industries but implement significant changes to improve the grid while also navigating its new governance structure and relationship with ERCOT.”

The company wanted funding for a staff to investigate trade information and up-to-date information administration instruments to investigate its personal information, the report mentioned.

The outcome was an overworked workers. Employees logged lengthy days and likewise labored weekends, lacking birthday celebrations and holidays to make necessary progress on legislative mandates, PUC Chair Peter Lake informed Sunset commissioners in December. They knew that they had a accountability to maintain the grid working, however Lake mentioned they had been working at an unsustainable tempo.

“I very much appreciate the comments about the staggering amount of increased responsibilities that have been assigned to this agency, very appropriately, in the aftermath of that storm,” Lake mentioned. “But the lack of resources, as y’all have identified, and the Sunset Commission identified, has made implementing all of the tasks y’all gave us very, very difficult.”

As of February 2022, simply over half the workers had been with the company for lower than 5 years, and nearly one-third had lower than two years’ service, in response to the report. The authorized division’s turnover price hit roughly 40% between 2020 and 2022, sparking concern amongst regulated industries that PUC attorneys lacked expertise and information.

Various associations and advocacy teams mentioned they assist growing the PUC’s finances. But they highlighted shortcomings they are saying want consideration.

Cyrus Reed, conservation director for the Lone Star Chapter of the Sierra Club, mentioned the PUC and grid operators must do a greater job planning for local weather extremes of their power demand planning and forecasting and be given extra capacity to watch the pure gasoline provide, resembling by way of an unbiased market monitor.

“They made some important progress, but not enough,” Reed mentioned in an interview Wednesday.