Southlake Carroll RB poised for season debut after UIL overturns eligibility ruling

The UIL state government committee made an extraordinary choice Monday morning to revisit and overturn a prior SEC ruling on a pupil shifting for athletic functions, granting a Southlake Carroll soccer participant eligibility to compete in varsity athletics this college yr.

Riley Wormley, a junior operating again who transferred from Colleyville Heritage to Carroll this offseason, was once deemed to have transferred for athletic functions all the way through an Aug. 7 SEC assembly with the UIL upholding the District 4-6A government committee ruling via a unanimous vote.

Wormley is a extremely touted recruit with scholarship provides from a number of of the area’s most sensible techniques, consistent with 247Sports, together with Oklahoma, TCU and Texas.

The DEC listening to was once prompted when first-year Heritage soccer trainer Jerry Edwards marked a clause on Wormley’s earlier athletic participation shape (PAPF) in May, pointing out he transferred for athletic causes.

But Monday — after Grapevine-Colleyville ISD asked to enchantment the SEC’s choice at the foundation of recent proof referring to Wormley’s lecturers — the UIL voted unanimously to overturn its choice.

It is now as much as Carroll ISD to finalize Wormley’s eligibility, however the UIL and DEC have lead the way. Carroll’s subsequent recreation is Oct. 5 at Keller.

“I’m just thankful for GCISD for righting their wrongs and giving me another opportunity,” Wormley advised The Dallas Morning News following the listening to.

Harsh punishments for transfers

The UIL opened Monday’s assembly via emphasizing how uncommon it’s to have a re-hearing. The UIL has in the past mentioned that impermissible shifting is one in all its most sensible problems of shock.

Historically, the UIL has overwhelmingly sided with district government committees, denying 71.8% of switch appeals since it all started monitoring SEC assembly ends up in its archives in 2013. That share has risen to 81.9% since 2020.

The UIL has proven in contemporary circumstances its willingness at hand out harsh punishments for transfers, stripping Duncanville boys basketball of its 2022 state identify after five-star recruit Anthony Black was once dominated ineligible after a switch from Coppell.

It additionally dominated 11 San Marcos soccer gamers ineligible for 3 years remaining fall for shifting to the college for athletic functions.

But SEC chair Mike Motheral stated the committee is open to re-hearings as soon as new proof is gifted.

Wormley’s circle of relatives stated the verdict to switch was once for instructional functions. His mom Erica Murphy stated GCISD didn’t successfully enforce lodging on Wormley’s Section 504 plan, which he has for dyslexia. Under Section 504 of the Rehabilitation Act, districts are required to offer scholars with a public schooling unfastened from discrimination for their disabilities.

His folks are divorced, and each reside in Euless within the zone for Heritage High School, however his father Adrian works as a faculty useful resource officer at Durham Intermediate School in Carroll ISD, which might make Wormley eligible to wait Southlake Carroll.

However, his choice to switch in April across the time of Carroll soccer’s spring practices raised considerations a number of the team of workers at Heritage and the UIL.

“There are some red flags,” Motheral stated all the way through the Aug. 7 listening to. “From my point of view, moving that time of year is kind of strange.”

UIL SEC individuals and representatives from the UIL concerned didn’t reply to requests for remark. Motheral declined to remark.

Validating instructional considerations

Approximately an hour ahead of the SEC’s Aug. 7 assembly the place Wormley’s enchantment was once denied, a Level Two complaint investigation was once finished via GCISD leader instructional officer Shiela Shiver and despatched to the UIL for evaluate.

The letter from Shiver, got via The News, mentioned that Wormley’s instructional struggles have been extra serious than the DEC will have been ended in imagine and that the district “did not complete an exhaustive search for information regarding the academic concerns for Riley.” She additionally discovered that required every year opinions of Wormely’s Section 504 plan weren’t performed.

UIL SEC individuals claimed they didn’t have get entry to to the Level Two complaint ahead of making their preliminary choice remaining month.

However, all the way through the Aug. 7 assembly, Motheral stated to Wormley’s mom, “I will remind you, we have had an opportunity to read through that. We did get it about an hour and a half ago. Glad that we had that opportunity.”

UIL deputy director Jamey Harrison additionally showed Monday that the committee gained the findings previous to the assembly.

“I guess I just hadn’t put it together that that was the result of the grievance,” Motheral stated Monday. “That’s my misunderstanding.”

The post-grievance findings have been in the end the proof that GCISD superintendent Brad Schnautz used to state publicly that his district had made a mistake.

“I’m saying that with this new information, it certainly validates academic concerns,” stated Schnautz, who was once the one GCISD consultant who spoke at the newest listening to. “I don’t believe we can truly say that he is transferring for athletic reasons.”

Colleyville Heritage athletic director Todd Raymond and District 4-6A government committee chair Joel Johnson have been each provide at Monday’s listening to. Edwards was once no longer provide, even though Schnautz reiterated to the committee that the first-year trainer have been at the task for “just a few weeks” when he stuffed out Wormley’s PAPF to the “best of his ability.”

GCISD, which supplied The News with a commentary on Edwards’ behalf, echoed Schnautz’s rationalization.

“At the time that the Previous Athletic Participation Form (PAPF) was completed, Coach Edwards followed the procedures as instructed by the UIL based on the information that he had about the student and their circumstances,” the commentary stated.

What’s subsequent?

Wormley, the country’s No. 32 operating again in step with 247sports within the Class of 2025, is now simply weeks clear of taking part in his first recreation for Carroll and will likely be a vital addition to a crew already off to a 5-0 get started.

He rushed for 182 yards and 5 touchdowns in his freshman season at Heritage underneath head trainer Kirk Martin, however was once restricted to simply 5 video games in 2022 because of an damage. Carroll trainer Riley Dodge didn’t in an instant reply to requests for remark Monday.

While he and his circle of relatives ultimately gained the result they was hoping for, the uncommon transfer Monday left the UIL state government committee all in favour of GCISD’s position and transparency all the way through the method.

The SEC thanked the district’s superintendent for correcting his team of workers’s errors, even though individuals warned the ones at the name of the ramifications in their movements.

“In a high school, we have an athletic coordinator that’s completing a form that really informs the path of a student moving forward,” stated SEC member Art Cavazos, a former superintendent at Harlingen CISD. “I would be very concerned if it becomes a pattern and we see this kind of behavior again from that school district.

“We would be remiss if we didn’t point out the fact that there’s a lot of missed opportunities here.”

On Twitter/X: @Lassimak

Find extra highschool sports activities protection from The Dallas Morning News right here.

Sign up for our FREE HS publication