Small Texas hospital tries new model aimed at saving rural health care

Sign up for The Brief, The Texas Tribune’s day by day publication that helps to keep readers on top of things at the maximum very important Texas news.

This tale used to be at first printed by means of Stateline, an initiative of The Pew Charitable Trusts.

BOWIE — After sitting empty and uncovered to thieves and vandals for greater than two years, the one-story hospital that served Bowie for greater than 5 a long time is on the subject of making a return — of varieties.

Reflecting the struggles dealing with hospitals all through rural America, Bowie Memorial Hospital has closed two times since 2015, the primary time when voters refused a tax-supported bailout, and once more in 2020, after a failed reopening.

Now, this north central Texas neighborhood of about 5,000 other people is partnering with a hospital machine in Jacksboro, about 30 miles away, to restore the brown brick construction on Greenwood Avenue as a round the clock emergency and remark heart. Bowie citizens who’ve needed to cross to different cities for emergency care eagerly look forward to its scaled-down reopening.

“We need a medical facility in our community above all,” 84-year-old Mildred McCraw mentioned at a contemporary public assembly to talk about the plan, pointing out herself “very ashamed” at the absence of a hospital.

The model taking shaping in Bowie exemplifies an rising thought for rescuing loads of failing rural hospitals — simply as federal bucks that experience helped many hospitals stave off cave in all over the COVID-19 pandemic are hastily drying up.

The objective of the federal Rural Emergency Hospital program, approved by Congress in 2020 and introduced in January, is to keep at least some health care services and products in rural communities that may’t fortify a full-fledged hospital. The program supplies higher Medicare payments and other dollars to small rural hospitals that shed inpatient services and products and as an alternative group of workers a round the clock emergency division and supply remark care.

Because Bowie Memorial Hospital closed earlier than the Rural Emergency Hospital program introduced, it isn’t eligible to take part. However, the city’s pursuit of the similar technique independently makes it a case find out about for a way this system would possibly play out in different places.

Other hospitals throughout Texas are making an allowance for converting their model underneath the Rural Emergency Hospital program, as are loads of failing hospitals in different states, mentioned Michael Topchik, who heads the Chicago-based Chartis Center for Rural Health, a consulting and analysis company.

The remodeled amenities will switch individuals who want inpatient care to full-service hospitals within reach. But for plenty of rural communities, the conversions to fewer services and products will probably be a sour tablet to swallow.

In Lock Haven, Pennsylvania, officers at UPMC Hospital say scaling again to an emergency division is “the best model of care to meet the needs of this community.” But Mayor Joel Long worries the absence of a full-scale native hospital may just endanger the more or less 8,000 citizens of Lock Haven.

“That travel time [to a full-scale hospital] could make all the difference in the world to one of our citizens,” he instructed Stateline. “You know — whether they survive or not.”

Shuttered hospitals, vanishing services and products

Health mavens have lengthy described the continued closures of rural hospitals as a disaster caused by a bunch of things, together with declining rural economies, shrinking populations, shortages of docs and nurses, mounting running prices and cuts in Medicare and Medicaid reimbursements.

Texas steadily is described because the epicenter of the rural hospital disaster, main the country with 26 transient or everlasting closures because the starting of 2010. But many states are suffering with the issue.

In a study the Chartis Center lately offered to political officers and health mavens in Washington, D.C., the group reported that 143 rural hospitals have closed over the last 13 years, and every other 453 are susceptible to closure. Moreover, expensive services and products reminiscent of obstetrics and chemotherapy “continue to vanish at an alarming rate,” the document mentioned.

At least 43% of the country’s rural hospitals are within the pink, however in states reminiscent of Texas that haven’t expanded Medicaid underneath the Affordable Care Act, greater than part of rural hospitals are dropping cash, in step with the document.

In Hamlin, a West Texas neighborhood of about 2,200 other people, a understand at the web site of the Hamlin Medical Clinic advises that, “Emergency Room and Inpatient Services have been permanently discontinued.” Hamlin closed its hospital just about 4 years in the past, changing it right into a walk-in health facility headed by means of Tonia Cook, a 46-year-old nurse practitioner who lives in Abilene.

“It’s a dwindling town,” Cook mentioned. “We’ve lost a lot of businesses. We have an aging population. We have a lot of unfunded patients.”

The Chartis Center find out about famous that the expiration of COVID-19-related help has exacerbated the commercial pressures using hospital closures. “As we move into a post-pandemic era, the long-term stability of the rural health safety net is strained,” the find out about states.

Sharp decline in Bowie

Bowie’s revel in illustrates what it’s like for a rural neighborhood to fight to rescue a hospital after which attempt to limp alongside with out it. “It stresses any community the size of ours to not have a local hospital,” Mayor Gaylynn Burris mentioned.

Named after Texas folks hero James Bowie, the neighborhood used to be based within the Eighties and advanced right into a regional industrial heart for farmers and ranchers. Its biggest vacationer appeal is a big 20-foot-long Bowie knife, paid for by means of native donations, which is indexed within the Guinness Book of World Records.

Lynn Heller, 74, served two stints as administrator of Bowie Memorial Hospital. During his 2nd tenure in 2015, the hospital used to be hopelessly within the pink. The best solution to stay it open, Heller believed, used to be to shape a hospital district to lift taxes and repay the debt. But electorate rejected the speculation, as they’d a equivalent proposal 4 years previous.

Two weeks after the 2015 election, the hospital closed. Heller and City Manager Bert Cunningham mentioned some citizens who voted in opposition to authorizing the taxing district regretted their motion and known as town corridor to take a look at to switch their vote. One of Heller’s pals moved his circle of relatives to Florida on account of his spouse’s clinical wishes.

“As far as I’m concerned, it had a very negative impact on the community,” he mentioned.

The Hashmi Group, a circle of relatives clinical workforce from the Dallas-Fort Worth house, purchased and reopened Bowie Memorial in 2017, however it closed once more in 2020, leaving the construction at the mercy of looters and vandals who stripped it of copper and used fireplace extinguishers to mar the partitions and flooring.

Janis Crawley, govt director of the Bowie Economic Development Corp., mentioned the closure resulted within the lack of 474 jobs, together with the hospital personnel and different jobs attached to the hospital. It took about 5 years for the neighborhood to recuperate from a 43% drop in gross sales tax income.

Crawley’s core challenge in recruiting companies to Bowie has additionally develop into a lot more difficult with out with the ability to cite a functioning hospital as one of the most attributes.

“It’s difficult because … one of the main things that people ask about when they’re moving to a community is, ‘Where’s the nearest hospital?’” Crawley mentioned.

Bowie has two clinics, however the nearest hospital is 21 miles away, in Nocona. Crawley mentioned she issues out to potential trade recruits that using there or to every other within reach hospital on an open Texas freeway can take much less time than touring a shorter distance in a congested metropolitan house. But to Bowie citizens, having to trip up to now is a trouble and can also be life-threatening.

“It’s a big inconvenience,” mentioned Chantel Housour, who runs an embroidery and attire retailer, recalling when she handled power critical migraines that required remedy at a hospital. “My only option was to go to the emergency room, so that means I’d go to either Decatur or Nocona because nothing was here.”

Bowie Fire Chief Doug Page mentioned his four-person division transports just about 2,000 sufferers a yr to one of the most out-of-the-town hospitals. “It’s not great,” he mentioned, “especially a town of 5,000 people, and you’re a long way from emergency medical care. You have clinics in town, but they’re not set up for critical patients, so we have to intervene.”

Earlier this month, 31 citizens confirmed up at the Bowie Community Center, inside of strolling distance of the large Bowie knife, for a presentation by means of Frank C. Beaman, the person in control of the hospital’s transformation.

“You’ve got to feel for the community,” Beaman mentioned in an interview later on. “Any community that loses a hospital … it’s just devastating.”

Although the timetable has been behind schedule by means of development setbacks linked to provide chain shortages and different problems, Beaman mentioned he’s hopeful the power can open someday round summer season. Crawley mentioned the citizens of Bowie will probably be satisfied each time the doorways swing open.

“They’re excited about it,” mentioned the commercial director. “No. 1, it’s going to bring back jobs. No. 2, it’s going to bring back the life to an entire block that has sat empty.”