Firefighter arbitration may be inevitable

WHO’S RUNNING? Houston mayoral applicants: Election key dates to understand and extra

State Sen. John Whitmire used to be adamant that resolving the years-long deadlock would be his most sensible precedence if elected, mentioning his initiation and passage of a regulation that makes binding arbitration the automated answer to contract stalemates in Houston. Previously, the town and the firefighters’ union needed to agree to visit arbitration, and the town rejected the union’s requests for the method.

“I passed legislation this spring requiring the city to sit down and go to mandatory arbitration,” Whitmire mentioned Monday. “We cannot have our major first responders as adversaries to City Hall. It’s just nuts. So they will be my highest priority.”

The solutions in Monday’s mayoral discussion board, hosted by means of the Greater Houston Women’s Chamber of Commerce, got here the similar day as legal professionals for the town requested a pass judgement on to claim Whitmire’s invoice unconstitutional as a result of they argued it unfairly goals Houston. The firefighters’ union is looking the pass judgement on to cause that regulation and ship the 2 facets to arbitration. 

The applicants’ weren’t explicitly requested whether or not they would drop the town’s criminal problem if the case continues into the following management, however a number of signaled they’d. Whitmire has mentioned the Turner management is “kicking the can down the road,” and previous Metro Chair Gilbert Garcia mentioned he would begin the method upon taking workplace. 

“My view is I would immediately go into arbitration with the firefighters because as mayor, my job would be to implement the will of the voters period,” Garcia mentioned. “I’m no longer right here to query the citizens. I’m no longer right here to be a dictator of the citizens, however to in point of fact put in force the desire of the citizens. And I in point of fact admire the senator striking ahead the invoice and make it a regulation to do such.”

BACKGROUND: Texas Supreme Court moves down Prop B, killing Houston firefighters’ pay parity measure

U.S. Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee mentioned the town is certain by means of the regulation now, regardless that she identified the Fiscal Year 2024 finances, which covers July 2023 thru June 2024, has already been finished, signaling there may most effective be room within the subsequent finances to reply to the dispute. The town and union nonetheless are sparring about which years are coated by means of the arbitration invoice.

“We’re going to have to deal with what was rendered,” U.S. Rep. Sheila Jackson Lee advised the Chronicle Monday. “It’s a bill that was passed in the state and we’re not going to be able to get past it.”

Attorney Lee Kaplan and businessman M.J. Khan mentioned they each disagreed with the town’s dealing with of the disputes. Khan felt negotiations have no longer been held in “good faith.” 

Kaplan mentioned the present management can be “faulted for not talking with the firefighters.” The town’s firefighters union is led by means of Marty Lancton, the president of Local 341. 

“As prickly as I hear Marty is, and I know he’s out there (in the crowd), I would still talk with him,” he mentioned. “If we have to go to an arbitration, we will if it busts a hole in the budget. Well, that’s what we signed up for.”

City Councilmember Robert Gallegos spoke out in give a boost to of the town, alternatively, mentioning that they’ve given 18-percent pay raises over 3 years to firefighters, in conjunction with raises for cops and municipal staff. He mentioned he would do what he may just to keep away from arbitration by means of settling the dispute in different ways if he’s elected. 

RELATED: City plans to problem invoice giving Houston firefighters arbitration in years-long pay dispute

“My office will always be open for the fire department union, for the police department union, as well as our municipal union to come in, to air out any grievances that they may have to see if we can take care of them before it goes into arbitration,” Gallegos mentioned.

The town, locked in court docket with the union since 2017, replied to the lawsuit by means of difficult the constitutionality of a key guideline of the regulation that governs how towns pay firefighters, contributing to years of long appeals that held up the problem. While that used to be on attraction, firefighters gained voter approval in 2018 of a town constitution modification that may have given them pay parity with cops of equivalent rank and seniority. 

Earlier this yr, a joint Supreme Court ruling threw out the town’s constitutional problem, whilst additionally putting down the firefighters’ pay parity initiative, sending the 2 facets again to court docket.

In Monday’s court docket listening to, attorneys for the union and the town clashed about whether or not Whitmire’s invoice is retroactive and must follow to the entire seven-year dispute. Judge Lauren Reeder didn’t factor a ruling on both facets’ requests.

Troy Blakeney, the union’s lead legal professional, advised throughout that assembly that the town is simply seeking to lengthen a answer to the deadlock.

“In this case, they don’t want (a resolution) at all,” he mentioned.

Election day is Nov. 7, and the closing day to sign in to vote is Oct. 10.

Reporter Dylan McGuinness contributed to this file.