FBI hate crime stats lack data from Florida agencies

The Federal Bureau of Investigation’s annual report on hate crimes launched in December lacks information from almost 40% of all of the regulation enforcement agencies within the nation — a proven fact that consultants say makes the data too incomplete to interpret precisely and will have detrimental penalties.

There had been 7,262 hate crimes within the nation in 2021, decrease than the 8,263 in 2020. But in 2021, 11,834 regulation enforcement agencies, or 63% of all agencies, reported their hate crimes, a big drop from when 15,138 agencies, or 81%, reported, the earlier 12 months.

One of the conclusions that may be drawn from the unfinished data, American University professor Cynthia Miller-Idriss stated, is that hate crimes elevated in 2021. But by how a lot is unknown.

“It’s impossible to use this data meaningfully,” Miller-Idriss stated.

The Seminole Police Department and the Miccosukee Police Department had been the one two agencies out of the 757 in Florida that submitted hate crime data to the FBI. The federal Bureau of Indian Affairs submitted the tribal agencies’ data, whereas the data for native regulation enforcement agencies is submitted by the Florida Department of Law Enforcement, FBI spokesperson Holly Morris stated in an e mail.

A Broward County family is accused of beating a homosexual Pompano Beach man so severely in August 2021 that he’s now completely blind, and the Fort Lauderdale Police Department documented eight hate crimes in 2021, 5 of which had been assault, battery or aggravated assault or battery.

Palm Beach County documented at the very least two hate crimes, data from the Palm Beach County Sheriff’s Office present. Miami-Dade County documented at the very least one in 2021.

Yet none are mirrored within the nationwide data. That’s the case for a lot of main metropolitan areas within the U.S., based on the FBI data.

[ RELATED: A family is accused of beating and blinding a man. They’ve pleaded not guilty to hate-crime charges. ]

Even with out most of the nation’s largest agencies and a few states reporting, the 7,262 hate crimes in 2021 is the third highest quantity in a decade, the Anti-Defamation League stated in an announcement.

“This, combined with the missing data from the large number of major cities [and Florida, plus most of California] that have historically reported some of the highest numbers of hate crimes, suggests that had more jurisdictions reported, the report likely would have shown record-high numbers,” the group’s assertion stated.

The report discovered that about 64% of all hate crimes had been motivated by race, ethnicity or ancestry bias. Sexual-orientation bias and faith bias had been the second and third commonest motivators.

Of the race-biased crimes, most had been motivated by anti-Black or African American bias whereas the vast majority of the religion-biased crimes had been anti-Jewish and the vast majority of sexuality-biased crimes had been anti-gay bias towards males.

“As a result of inflamed rhetoric, we are seeing instances of both racism and antisemitism. Both types of hate are two sides of the same coin,” stated Evan Goldman, government director, public affairs of the Jewish Federation of Broward County.

The Broward State Attorney’s Office created a brand new Hate Crimes Unit in March and considered one of its objectives is to extend native reporting of hate crimes. Goldman stated he’s inspired by the creation of the unit and its Broward County Hate Crimes Task Force, which the federation participates in.

“It sends a signal that the State Attorney is bringing together the appropriate stakeholders, be it law enforcement, community partners and even municipalities all working together to combat hate. You can’t do it in a silo,” Goldman stated.

The FBI switched to utilizing the National Incident-Based Reporting System, NIBRS, to report hate crime statistics in January 2021.

The new system will enable for “significantly more detailed data” to be compiled, however many agencies didn’t transition on time, inflicting the drop in reporting not just for hate crimes however all crimes, the FBI stated in an announcement Dec. 12.

Aside from almost no participation in Florida, the vast majority of agencies in California didn’t take part, in addition to a few of the largest cities, together with New York City and Los Angeles, based on the Anti-Defamation League.

The Broward Sheriff’s Office and several other different agencies in Broward County submit their crime statistics to the state and ultimately to the FBI by means of a data administration system maintained by the county, Miranda Grossman, a Sheriff’s Office spokesperson, stated in an e mail.

The Sheriff’s Office and others that use the county’s system weren’t in a position to meet the FBI’s deadline “due to vendor software issues related to” the transition, Grossman stated, and is working to submit the data “as soon as possible.”

The Fort Lauderdale Police Department sometimes submits its hate crime statistics to the FBI however didn’t for 2021, additionally attributable to points transitioning to the brand new system, Det. Ali Adamson, a division spokesperson, stated in an e mail. The division will submit its statistics starting in early 2023.

“The hate crimes continue to increase almost daily in our communities, so these statistics are needed so that we can address those issues, not only at the county level but at the municipal level as well,” stated Broward County Mayor Lamar Fisher, a member of the Florida Hate Crime Coalition.

“Any kind of data that you collect and study over a year or two period can dictate what actions need to be taken,” Fisher stated.

Brendan Lantz, an assistant professor in Florida State University’s College of Criminology and Criminal Justice, stated he helps the transition to NIBRS as a result of it should enable agencies to offer way more in-depth particulars about crimes, together with information about offenders’ and victims’ ages, races and intercourse, ethnicities, kinds of accidents, whether or not weapons had been concerned and extra. The previous technique solely allowed for agencies to supply an mixture rely.

Participation within the new system has improved, the FBI stated in its assertion. As of Nov. 1, 12,090 in a foreign country’s over 18,800 agencies have reported crime data by means of NIBRS.

But the FBI data launched this 12 months, Lantz stated, is “essentially unusable.” FBI hate crime statistics have at all times been underreported, and this years report reveals “our hate crime statistics have gotten even worse than they were before.”

“What we had up until this year was essentially at least consistent variation so we could at least, if not know the true number of hate crimes that were occurring each year, have some sense for changes between years … Now, that’s not the case,” Lantz stated.

“I’ve always said that the biggest barrier to hate crime research is how difficult it is to define the problem. It’s difficult to define the problem because our data aren’t very good, and you can’t really start to develop a solution until you truly understand the problem.”

Miller-Idriss, professor within the Department of Justice, Law and Criminology at American University, stated the FBI shouldn’t have launched the 2021 data publicly with such little participation and uneven reporting.

The report will not be consultant of what’s occurring within the nation, Miller-Idriss stated, when data from locations the place hate crimes are identified to be on the rise are lacking, like in New York City and Los Angeles.

Such underreported data can gasoline a lack of belief between victims of hate crimes and regulation enforcement when susceptible communities don’t really feel they’re represented within the nationwide image and will have an effect on regulation enforcement agencies’ and different authorities’ choices transferring ahead, Miller-Idriss stated.

“If people think the numbers are going down, then that has implications for where they’ll devote time and resources,” she stated.

Miller-Idriss stated she hopes to see reporting hate crimes to the FBI turn into necessary and that receiving federal funding be contingent on taking part in reporting hate crime statistics.

“I’m completely baffled by it to be honest,” she stated. “I think there’s a pretty widespread reaction to it, and I think people understand that it is flawed, in part because seeing the numbers go down doesn’t reflect what so many local jurisdictions are saying is happening.”

States that had considerably low participation within the FBI program ought to make it a precedence to launch correct information on the state degree, Miller-Idriss stated.

“I know that there are local reporting efforts, and they just didn’t make it into the data,” she stated. ”I feel that’s actually essential for folks to know on the bottom.”

In 2020, Miami-Dade and Broward County had the first- and second-highest variety of hate crimes within the state, based on state-level data.

Florida has seen an increase in hate crimes over the previous a number of years, based on a September report by the Anti-Defamation League Center on Extremism. Nearly the entire religiously-motivated hate crimes within the state in 2020 had been anti-Jewish, and antisemitic hate crimes have elevated by 300% since 2012.

“Underreporting of hate crimes in Florida and nationwide is a severe obstacle to tracking, investigating and prosecuting these crimes; this in turn leads to a lack of accountability for bias-motivated offenses that can intimidate, isolate and terrorize entire communities,” the report stated.

Three youngsters had been arrested in November on felony expenses associated to racist and antisemitic messages spray-painted in Weston on three separate days in October. Two of the teenagers’ expenses had a hate crime enhancement.

[ RELATED: Three teens face felony charges related to antisemitic and racist messages spray-painted in Weston ]

Fort Lauderdale Police Department’s hate crime statistics present 16 verified hate crimes occurred in 2022 — the very best since at the very least 2015.

Several swastikas had been spray painted on the facet of a Fort Lauderdale house within the 5000 block of Northeast seventeenth Road in July 2022, together with the phrase Azov, a Ukrainian ultra-right paramilitary group that advocates white supremacist views together with a pro-Ukrainian banner within the yard, a police report stated. The resident of the house advised police she will not be Jewish and didn’t know who was answerable for the graffiti.

Also lately in Fort Lauderdale, a girl who lives within the 1000 block of Southeast seventeenth Street referred to as police in August 2022 as a result of somebody destroyed a Jewish image that was held on her door, based on a police report.

In December 2022 alone, Fort Lauderdale Police documented 5 hate crimes, motivated by anti-LGBTQ, anti-Jewish and anti-Black bias, the division’s statistics present.

Information from The Associated Press was used on this report.