Last month, Icahn began a related struggle at Kroger Co., the Cincinnati-based grocery large whose shops embody Fred Meyer, Kroger and Ralphs – this time tying collectively the poor remedy of animals and staff, who he claimed had been underpaid throughout the pandemic. “What has happened at Kroger with the issues of animal welfare and employee wages is an affront to the basic fibers of our society — that of decency and dignity,” Icahn wrote in a letter explaining his choice to appoint two administrators to the corporate’s board.
Animal-rights organizations have lengthy tried to make use of shareholder activism to advance their objectives, with little success. Back in 2008, the U.S. Humane Society sought a shareholder decision on phasing out the usage of gestation crates at Tyson Foods Inc. The proposal failed spectacularly, as most shareholder proposals do. Even when one passes, corporations aren’t obligated to comply with by way of and infrequently do.
Icahn isn’t a main investor in both McDonald’s or Kroger: The corporations have reported his holdings as 200 and 100 shares, respectively. Yet he has a lot that the everyday small shareholder doesn’t, together with a larger megaphone, a large checkbook and a posse of legal professionals at his disposal. Such sources matter. When activist investor Engine No. 1 nominated 4 administrators to Exxon Mobil Corp. and in the end gained three board seats, the estimated price for each events was round $60 million. It’s protected to say that proxy fights at McDonald’s and Kroger will price at the least a number of million {dollars}, it doesn’t matter what the end result. Company executives are taking the problem severely: In latest months, McDonald’s CEO Chris Kempczinski has participated in at the least three cellphone calls with Icahn about gestation crates, in keeping with the latter’s proxy assertion.
One huge query is why somebody as notoriously profit-focused as Icahn would commit himself to a battle over animal rights. Perhaps, given the rise of ESG investing, he thinks treating pigs and folks higher will really enhance inventory costs — however along with his tiny holdings, he wouldn’t stand to achieve a lot. He additionally has lengthy demonstrated a ardour for the difficulty, having gotten concerned a decade in the past, when the Humane Society tried to appoint its CEO on the time, Wayne Pacelle, to Tyson’s board. Icahn served as an advisor in that effort, although the nomination was in the end dropped.
McDonald’s and Kroger usually maintain their annual conferences in late May and late June, respectively, so there’s nonetheless time for each side to sharpen their swords. Icahn isn’t recognized for giving up, and this time he’s really doing the nominating, somewhat than simply advising. With his in depth expertise waging proxy fights, to not point out shifting public opinion on the remedy of animals, he would possibly be capable to obtain far more than rights activists may have on their very own.
This column doesn’t essentially mirror the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its house owners.
Michelle Leder is an knowledgeable on SEC filings, having launched her website, Footnoted.com, in 2003 after writing the ebook “Financial Fineprint: Uncovering a Company’s True Value.”
More tales like this can be found on bloomberg.com/opinion