Why Texas doesn’t teach consent in its sex ed curriculum

Sign up for The Brief, our each day e-newsletter that retains readers in control on essentially the most important Texas news.

If you or somebody you realize has been sexually assaulted, you may obtain confidential assist by calling the Rape, Abuse & Incest National Network’s 24/7 toll-free assist line at 800-656-4673 or visiting its online hotline.

Millions of scholars returning to public faculties throughout Texas are encountering fallout from a battle over the state’s first main replace to sex training and well being requirements in greater than twenty years.

A Newsy investigation revealed how an advocacy group helped persuade the Texas State Board of Education to strike classes about consent from the state’s deliberate well being training requirements for the 2022-23 college 12 months. The board’s determination went towards the recommendation of medical consultants and organizations selling teen sexual well being, which say complete sex training helps scale back rape and undesirable pregnancies.

“It’s not an open communication — to talk about sex,” mentioned 17-year-old Kennia Gonzalez, a senior at Brownsville Early College High School in Texas. Gonzalez mentioned her highschool doesn’t teach any type of sex training past abstinence. “Teachers aren’t supposed to talk about it with students,” she mentioned.

In reality, Texas excessive faculties usually are not required to supply college students sex training, and in the event that they do, dad and mom should choose in for his or her youngsters to obtain it. State laws now require these faculties that select to teach the subject to emphasise “the centrality of abstinence education in any human sexuality curriculum.”

The state of Texas’ excessive hopes for convincing teenagers to say no to sex don’t look like having the supposed affect. A 2019 Centers for Disease Control and Prevention survey of Texas youths confirmed that just about two-thirds of highschool seniors report having had sex. Texas has the ninth-highest teen birth rate in the U.S., and the state tops the nation in repeat teen births.

Gonzalez mentioned with no sex training being taught by her college, a few of her classmates are left with harmful gaps in their understanding of wholesome sex and relationships.

“Men are taught to get what they want without the teaching of consent,” she mentioned. “So, they’re just like, ‘She will say yes because I’m a macho man.’ And that’s how rape happens.”

A spokesperson for the Brownsville Independent School District didn’t reply to a number of requests for feedback about their curriculum.

According to the 2019 CDC Youth Risk Behavior Survey, practically 1 in 7 highschool senior women mentioned they’ve been bodily pressured to have sexual activity. In Texas, that quantity is nearer to 1 in 5, in keeping with the state model of the identical survey.

The battle over consent in Texas 

Records from the State Board of Education in Texas, reviewed by Newsy, inform the story of a nonprofit group named the Medical Institute for Sexual Health that performed an influential function in convincing the state board to maintain consent out of Texas necessities — towards the recommendation of well being consultants and organizations pushing to stop sexual violence.

Recommendations to the state board for brand new requirements for the 2022-23 college 12 months in Texas did embrace classes on instructing college students about consent on the seventh- and eighth-grade ranges. In Texas, center faculties are required to supply some sex training, although a brand new state regulation makes dad and mom choose in first. Educators, dad and mom and different advocacy teams expressed to state officers their assist for instructing consent.

The Texas Medical Association and Texas Pediatric Society collectively wrote to the State Board of Education “on behalf of more than 53,000 physicians in Texas” to say they “strongly support adding new standards on boundaries and consent for physical intimacy where none previously existed.” The teams added that college students ought to “understand affirmative consent is required in all physically intimate encounters.”

The Texas chapter of the National Association of Social Workers additionally wrote to the board: “Consent is an extremely important part of any conversation regarding healthy relationships. We believe that it is the SBOE’s duty to include clear, informative, and meaningful definitions of consent, including examples of how a student might share their consent within relationships of any kind.”

But in keeping with state information, the Medical Institute for Sexual Health and greater than 1,000 neighborhood members “expressed opposition to any efforts to add language discussing consent” to the state’s minimal well being requirements. The group additionally instructed the State Board of Education it supported “the omission of differentiated instruction on lesbian, gay, bisexual, transgender, and queer (LGBTQ) issues” for this college 12 months.

The Medical Institute for Sexual Health, a Dallas-based nonprofit based in 1992, is an abstinence-promoting group lively in a number of states. The group distributes guidelines for sex education that, regardless of the group’s title, have been criticized by some in the medical neighborhood. Researchers from Columbia University, Johns Hopkins, Case Western and others wrote in the Journal of Adolescent Health in 2021 that the group’s requirements have been “seriously flawed from both scientific and human rights’ perspectives.”

State information present the Medical Institute performed a bigger function in shaping the brand new requirements in Texas, past merely submitting feedback. The group’s director of science on the time is listed as serving on two of the Texas Education Agency’s working teams that drafted proposals for the brand new well being requirements. The group’s president on the time, Lori Kuykendall, mentioned she served on a number of working teams that labored “to craft the language” for the proposed sexual well being requirements. After an early draft of the center college requirements nonetheless included consent, Kuykendall spoke at a State Board of Education assembly to say that there was a “slip of consent in grade seven and eight” that remained in proposed requirements. She requested the board to “not include consent.”

One of the Medical Institute’s board members, Dr. Jack Lesch, was tapped by the State Board of Education to function one among simply six content advisers who took suggestions that got here out of the working teams and drafted them into one new proposal for minimal requirements for the state board to think about. He really helpful the board strike instructing consent from varied components of the brand new requirements, stating: “There are extensive references to refusal skills, safe and personal boundaries, setting limits in the SE’s. Therefore, recommend DELETE consent from the topic of decision-making.”

Lesch additionally wrote to the state board to say that introducing consent is “unnecessary” and “also encourages moving toward sexual behavior that is better to delay (avoid).” State information present that some content material advisers disagreed with Lesch.

The state board finally mentioned it agreed with the Medical Institute’s place on omitting LGBTQ instruction from the minimal requirements for this college 12 months. As to the Medical Institute’s request to steer clear from “any” instruction on consent, the information additional notice, “The SBOE agrees and has determined that sexual consent was not appropriate” in the Texas requirements. The board then “took action to eliminate” a reference to consent.

State Board of Education Chair Keven Ellis didn’t reply to an emailed request for remark. A spokesperson for the Texas Education Agency confirmed fundamental information in regards to the state’s requirements however didn’t reply to requests for remark in regards to the state board’s decision-making on the problem of consent.

Attempts to achieve Lesch, the Medical Institute’s board member, by phone, textual content message and e-mail have been unsuccessful. The Medical Institute’s then-president, Kuykendall, responded in writing to emailed questions.

“Children under the age of 17 cannot legally give consent to sexual activity and should not be instructed how to,” she wrote. “If the goal is to empower children to know when they are being violated and what to do to resist, avoid, or run away from the perpetrator (and ultimately report), then it is logical they would be taught refusal or resistance skills.”

Instead of consent, the state board adopted requirements that mirrored the Medical Institute’s steering to instruct faculties to teach refusal expertise and private boundaries, and state information present they determined to teach even these solely “at some grade levels.”

“As far as I’m concerned, [consent] is one of the most important things you can be teaching,” mentioned Shael Norris, govt director of SafeBAE, a nationwide advocacy group working to stop sexual violence amongst middle- and high-school college students. 

Norris was essential of the state’s final option to teach refusal expertise with out additionally instructing consent.

“Instead of putting the blame where it belongs on the perpetrator, the victim takes on that responsibility, and that makes them that much more vulnerable to suicide — if they are victimized and they feel responsible for it,” she mentioned.

There will not be a lot tutorial analysis but into the affect that classes on consent would have on decreasing sexual assaults, however studies show that individuals who have been sexually assaulted are at practically 3 times larger danger of suicidal ideation or suicide makes an attempt.

Norris mentioned advocates like her agree that consent classes might be taught in an age-appropriate, nonsexual method to youngsters as younger as in kindergarten. An instance she cites is instructing a younger youngster it’s OK for them to say sure or no to hugs, high-fives or different types of nonsexual contact. This can kind a constructing block to teach different kinds of consent for older youngsters.

The present leaders on the Medical Institute for Sexual Health didn’t reply to a number of requests for an interview, however the group’s founder and CEO, Dr. Joe McIlhaney, did reply questions in writing by a public relations agency.

In response to questions asking if the Medical Institute would assist any classes on consent for prime schoolers, or “nonsexual” consent classes for college kids of any age, McIlhaney mentioned his group “believes that school-age children understand the meaning of ‘yes’ and ‘no.’ We believe that they should refuse sexual advances, and not wonder whether they could or should give consent at such a young age. The answer should be ‘no.’”

The American Academy of Pediatrics, representing 67,000 pediatricians, mentioned packages selling abstinence have “conclusively” been shown not to work however that the majority complete sexuality education schemes studied have been proven to delay the age of intercourse and to advertise “protective behaviors” like condom use. And a 2016 United Nations study of 48 countries found that complete sexuality training results in “the reduction of sexually transmitted infections (STIs), HIV, and unintended pregnancy.”

The AAP and a number of different medical and academic authorities, such because the American Medical Association and the National Education Association, endorse instructing consent.

Crime statistics from the Texas Department of Public Safety’s 2020 report reveal the 2 age teams with the very best variety of reported sexual assault victims in the state have been 15- to 19-year-olds and 10- to 14-year-olds. Altogether, a Newsy evaluation discovered that youngsters and youngsters 19 and youthful made up greater than two-thirds of sexual assault victims in Texas.

Melanie Ramirez, the director of prevention packages on the Texas Association Against Sexual Assault, a nonprofit related to 70 rape disaster facilities throughout Texas — and one of many teams that attempted to get consent added to the brand new state requirements — mentioned instructing solely refusal and boundary expertise is outdated and dangerous.

“It’s reiterating an old notion that if you experience sexual violence, it’s somehow now your fault,” she mentioned.

“We’re not trying to teach, ‘Don’t get raped.’ We’re trying to teach, ‘Don’t rape.’”

A nationwide debate

Nationwide, 29 states require that college students obtain sex training, and 13 require they find out about consent, in keeping with the Sexual Information and Education Council of the United States, or SIECUS. But the battle to vary that’s hitting state legislatures and native college boards throughout the nation. Alison Macklin, a coverage and advocacy director for SIECUS, mentioned in greater than 60 years her group has by no means seen as many payments proposed to limit sex training as what occurred in the 2022 state legislative classes.

“This is the busiest we have been in tracking these types of bills,” Macklin mentioned.

Lessons about gender id and consent have additionally impressed passionate dad and mom and arranged teams on either side of the talk to storm into usually tranquil college board conferences. Some are calling to limit or dispose of sex training in faculties altogether.

A Miami-Dade college board assembly made national headlines in July when police have been known as to take away dad and mom who disrupted the talk on whether or not to undertake a pair of sex-education textbooks that had references to subjects like being pregnant and sexually transmitted illnesses. The highschool textbook mentioned consent “occurs when someone clearly says yes” in “words, not just body language.” The board initially voted to take the books out of the curriculum for this college 12 months, leaving college students with no sex-education curriculum, till a brand new spherical of upset dad and mom later satisfied the board to reinstate the books.

At the Nebraska State Board of Education assembly final August, one particular person upset over the proposed requirements in that state appeared to threaten a Jan. 6-style rebellion, whereas others in contrast the board to Nazis due to the proposed curriculum, which included the instructing of consent.

In Oregon, a nonprofit group known as Parents’ Rights in Education, or PRIE, not too long ago hosted its second annual summit to coach dad and mom from across the nation on how you can grow to be extra politically lively the place they stay, whereas attempting to vote out college board members who don’t conform to hold consent and complete sex training out of college curriculum. The group mentioned on its web site it was established in 2011. The group’s govt director, Suzanne Gallagher, is the former head of the Oregon Republican Party.

“This is political,” Gallagher mentioned. “People like to deny that. They want to think, ‘Oh, it’s just a school.’ It has everything to do with politics. We’re flipping school boards.”

PRIE’s web site says complete sexual training shouldn’t be taught in faculties as a result of “teaching consent undermines any semblance of an abstinence message.”

Her podcast web site refers to literature that claims academics who present sex training are implementing a “Molester’s Manifesto,” whereas additionally claiming in a bullet level “1 in 10 children will experience school employee sexual misconduct.”

Newsy traced Gallagher’s statistic to a examine printed by the U.S. Department of Education in 2004. The assessment included knowledge from an earlier examine that discovered that 1 in 10 college students had skilled sexual harassment from educators — which included issues like name-calling, spreading rumors and inappropriate jokes. Though the writer of the 2004 assessment recharacterized this as “sexual misconduct,” the Department of Education added a preface cautioning that misconduct and abuse weren’t one and the identical.

Newsy made Gallagher conscious of the division’s considerations and famous her personal podcast web site used “misconduct” statistics to assist claims about youngster molestation in faculties. Gallagher stood by her web site and, on the time of publication, it was left unchanged.

Gallagher mentioned she nonetheless believes college students are extra susceptible to sexual abuse by academics if they’re taught it’s ever OK to consent to a sexual encounter.

“They’re going to be thinking, ‘Oh, yeah, you know, Mr. Smith, who is just a stud, he said I could,” explains Gallagher. “It’s setting students up to be accepting of sexual advances from anyone, thinking that it’s OK, it’s all right, it’s perfectly normal, there’s absolutely nothing wrong with it and I have a right to it. That goes against the values of many families.”

Gallagher mentioned her message is reducing by on the poll field and has, together with the work of different dad and mom’ rights teams, helped drive a changeover in college board members in Newberg, Oregon. She additionally factors to Texas as a state the place Parents’ Rights In Education is lively.

“We have a couple groups in Texas. They’re on fire there,” she mentioned.

Efforts to get sex training out of public faculties fear Dr. M. Brett Cooper, a pediatrician who practices in Dallas and is educated particularly in adolescent well being, with a grasp’s in training. He spoke publicly to the Texas State Board of Education on the significance of instructing consent whereas representing the Texas Medical Association and Texas Pediatric Society.

Cooper mentioned he sees firsthand as a working towards doctor how widespread it’s for fogeys to shrink back from instructing their very own youngsters about sex.

“Parents often come to me when they find out that their child has had sex. I ask them if they’ve talked to their child about these things before. The answer is usually no,” he mentioned.

A Harvard Graduate School of Education survey of 18- to 25-year-olds discovered that the majority respondents “had never spoken with their parents about things like ‘being sure your partner wants to have sex and is comfortable doing so before having sex.’”

Kennia Gonzalez, who says she is the daughter of a teen mom, mentioned that if faculties don’t teach youngsters complete sex training, they’re going to get it from much less respected sources, just like the web.

“They’re going to explore, and not giving them that education isn’t going to stop them,” she mentioned. “I want the teen pregnancy and [sexual assault] percentages to go down. I just want to see a change.”

Zach Cusson and Meghan Sullivan with Newsy/Scripps Washington Bureau contributed reporting for this story.

Disclosure: Texas Medical Association has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news group that’s funded in half by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Financial supporters play no function in the Tribune’s journalism. Find an entire list of them here.

The full program is now LIVE for the 2022 Texas Tribune Festival, occurring Sept. 22-24 in Austin. Explore the schedule of 100+ mind-expanding conversations coming to TribFest, together with the within observe on the 2022 elections and the 2023 legislative session, the state of public and better ed at this stage in the pandemic, why Texas suburbs are booming, why broadband entry issues, the legacy of slavery, what actually occurred in Uvalde and a lot extra. See the program.