Texas to execute Tracy Beatty for strangling mother to death

Sign up for The Brief, our each day e-newsletter that retains readers up to velocity on probably the most important Texas news.

The state plans to execute Tracy Beatty on Wednesday night for murdering his mother in East Texas in 2003.

Beatty, now 61, was discovered responsible of fatally strangling Carolyn Click, the tip of a violent and tumultuous relationship. Though they acknowledge Beatty killed his mother, his attorneys have contended the crime doesn’t qualify for the death penalty.

To be sentenced to death in Texas, an individual should be convicted of not simply homicide, however capital homicide, a selected authorized subset that features killing a police officer or younger youngster, killing a number of folks, or killing somebody whereas committing one other felony like theft or rape.

Though Beatty gave a number of variations of what occurred in his 62-year-old mother’s death, in accordance to courtroom data, he finally advised police that he got here residence drunk, the pair began preventing, and he choked her. He mentioned he didn’t notice Click was useless till the subsequent day.

But Beatty was discovered responsible of capital homicide as a result of prosecutors argued he killed his mother throughout a house housebreaking, coming into with out her consent, although he lived with Click on the time. A neighbor testified that Click had advised her the day she was final seen that she had advised her son that day to transfer out after a battle.

“The evidence of entry without consent in this case is thin, and the evidence of intent to commit a felony, theft, or assault even thinner,” wrote former Texas Court of Criminal Appeals Judge Cheryl Johnson in 2009, joined by two others in dissent of the 5-3 opinion upholding Beatty’’s death sentence. “There is no doubt that [Beatty] killed Click; the issue is whether the burglary was proven and thus whether the offense is capital murder or murder.”

The dissenting judges pointed to the testimony of Click’s different neighbor, Lieanna Wilkerson, who mentioned the mother and son argued each day. Wilkerson additionally mentioned Click had advised Beatty to transfer out earlier than, and every time the mother allowed him to keep or let him transfer again in shortly thereafter.

A majority of judges have affirmed Beatty’s death sentence, nevertheless, partly due to his violent relationship together with his mother. In the 2009 majority opinion by the Court of Criminal Appeals, the judges famous Wilkerson had additionally testified that Beatty had beforehand overwhelmed his mother, as soon as so severely he had “left her for dead.”

The judges mentioned Beatty, jobless and poor, was possible offended at his mother for controlling him, one time refusing to drive him to a job interview as a result of “she just didn’t feel like it,” in accordance to Wilkerson.

“A rational jury could infer that [Beatty] was angry after Click told him to get out and that he entered Click’’s house with intent to assault her again or kill her, or at least take some of her money or her possessions,” the courtroom majority wrote.

Beatty had been launched from jail on parole months earlier than Click’s death. Prosecutors at trial listed a slew of his earlier legal fees, together with injuring a jail guard and assaulting an 18-month-old youngster.

In latest makes an attempt to cease his death, Beatty’s attorneys revealed that one of many trial jurors knew his mother and didn’t say something. They argued this introduced an unacceptable degree of bias to his verdict and sentence.

The Court of Criminal Appeals dismissed the argument, stating it didn’t meet the state’s strict necessities for reduction in a late attraction, together with that the invention might have been made earlier.

In one other courtroom battle, Beatty’s attorneys argued the state’s jail system didn’t permit them to correctly consider the prisoner for attainable cognitive defects or mental disabilities that may bar him from execution.

When Beatty’s attorneys sought psychological evaluations this 12 months to weigh a attainable mental incapacity declare or psychological competency, the Texas Department of Criminal Justice’s refused to unshackle him throughout the examinations. The resolution was atypical, his attorneys claimed, and prevented psychological well being professionals from finishing a full analysis.

Amanda Hernandez with the Texas Department of Criminal Justice mentioned final week that the company adopted commonplace protocol to shield prisoners, workers, and guests. Federal courts famous TDCJ started requiring courtroom orders to unshackle prisoners throughout professional evaluations final 12 months, although with out an official coverage change.

Federal protection attorneys mentioned regardless of “significant red flags for mental impairments,” Beatty had by no means been psychologically evaluated by knowledgeable employed by his attorneys within the attraction course of. Such purple flags included Beatty being despatched this 12 months to the psychiatric jail facility after experiencing visible and auditory hallucinations, the attorneys mentioned.

They argued correct evaluations are vital to decide whether or not the prisoner is mentally incompetent or has an mental incapacity that may bar his execution on constitutional grounds. Federal courts declined to intervene, with judges from the U.S. fifth Circuit Court of Appeals saying there was no justification the attraction was something apart from a delay tactic. A federal district choose echoed the sentiment, stating the declare Beatty had “a long history of mental illness” meant Beatty might have been evaluated a lot earlier. Beatty has appealed the rulings to the U.S. Supreme Court.

Without intervention by the Supreme Court or Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, Beatty might be executed in Huntsville after 6 p.m. It would be the state’s fourth execution of the 12 months. Seven others are scheduled in Texas by way of September.

The Texas Tribune is a nonprofit statewide news group devoted to preserving Texans knowledgeable on politics and coverage points that impression their communities. This election season, Texans across the state will flip to The Texas Tribune for the information they want on voting, election outcomes, evaluation of key races and extra. Get the latest.