As keen as postwar Germany has been to atone for its Nazi previous, there’s no likelihood that Berlin pays any of this sum, because the Poles are nicely conscious. But that’s not what that is about. Instead, the gesture by Poland’s hard-right Law and Justice occasion (PiS) speaks volumes about different afflictions ailing the European Union.
To wit: There’s the rise of populism and nationalism in a number of member states, which will likely be on notably vivid show in PiS’s marketing campaign for subsequent 12 months’s election. Then there’s the contentious and ambiguous function of Germany inside the EU, a bloc it most likely ought to, however both can’t or received’t lead. And there’s the best way all of the ensuing tensions preserve irritating the EU’s raison d’etre — the interior reconciliation that may permit its nations to collectively confront exterior threats akin to an autocratic Russia.
There’s no level in arguing concerning the quantity, 1.3 trillion. A “true” quantity — tallied in human struggling in addition to materials harm — could be uncountable multiples greater.
And that’s the place the issues begin, as seen from Berlin — or certainly from another world capital that after ordered or oversaw atrocities dedicated in its identify someplace. Once you begin compensating the descendants of some victims, the place and when do you cease?
Berlin’s official reply to all reparations calls for — Greece is one other nation that retains asking — is frustratingly legalistic. After World War II, West Germany paid nominal indemnities to Israel, Yugoslavia and different nations. East Germany indemnified its communist massive brother, the Soviet Union, which was in flip presupposed to allot a part of the sums to its communist little brother, Poland.
During the Cold War, the Germans due to this fact deemed different individuals’s warfare claims both settled or nonetheless pending a ultimate association with the Allied Powers. That closure got here in 1990, with the Two Plus Four Treaty among the many two Germanies and the Soviet Union, US, UK and France.
Since then, the Germans have maintained — as Chancellor Olaf Scholz once more advised the Poles final week — that the books are closed. As the Greeks joke: Before reunification, the Germans mentioned it was too early to barter; afterwards, they mentioned it was too late.
But to get slowed down in such hairsplitting, the Germans prefer to level out, is to overlook the entire spirit of European integration. It’s presupposed to be a “peace project,” an idealistic leap of reconciliation, as embodied within the mutual embrace of Germany and France — enemies-turned-friends, with aspirations to change into household.
Poland, like the opposite member states previously behind the Iron Curtain, entered the EU late and had completely different motivations for becoming a member of. It was in a rush to flee Russia’s orbit and enter the West’s. But quite than submerge its id into a brand new European one, it additionally wished to catch up by itself nation-building, after centuries throughout which it was partitioned, moved, invaded and laid low with individuals talking both German or Russian — and typically, as in 1939, by each.
Simultaneously, the entire EU has for years been debating the most recent iteration of the previous “German question.” This is the recurring drawback that Germany, smack in the course of Europe, is both too weak (as within the seventeenth or early nineteenth centuries) or too robust (within the late nineteenth and early twentieth) to permit stability within the continental states system. Today’s model may be that Germany is too small to guide however too massive to observe.
The EU, whose founding establishments had been designed within the ashes of a German warfare of aggression, was constructed to stop any member nation, and particularly Germany, from ever once more dominating the others. At the identical time, the membership — with 27 members and extra within the queue — is fragmented and dysfunctional sufficient to want management, a job for which its largest nation is the apparent candidate.
In Germany, this conundrum led to a protracted “hegemony debate.” Most Germans, nonetheless traumatized by the Nazi previous, reject the function of chief — it doesn’t assist that the phrase interprets to Fuehrer. They usually quote the author Thomas Mann, who feared a “German Europe” whereas craving for a “European Germany.” During the euro, refugee and different crises, nevertheless, Germans additionally realized that the EU solely capabilities when Germany takes the initiative.
Other Europeans have been simply as torn. They detest being lectured by Germans — on how to save cash, in Athens or Madrid; on how you can uphold the rule of legislation, in Warsaw or Budapest; on something, in Paris or Rome. In Brussels, Germans usually come throughout as humorless and hypocritical, the worst mixture. One of the primary international locations, together with France, to interrupt the EU’s vaunted fiscal guidelines — initially drafted by the Germans — was Germany itself, in 2005.
But most Europeans additionally perceive the necessity to reconcile with Germany and to implicitly accede to its management. “I will probably be the first Polish foreign minister in history to say so,” quipped Radoslaw Sikorski in 2011, when he was Warsaw’s chief diplomat, “but here it is: I fear German power less than I am beginning to fear German inactivity.” Yet he added: “Provided you include us in decision-making, Poland will support you.”
Since Sikorski’s comment, issues have principally deteriorated. In 2015, Poland adopted the instance of Hungary and elected populist nationalists who’ve been in energy since. Step by step, PiS has compromised judicial independence, press freedoms and the rights of LGBTQ residents, whereas ranting towards Brussels and Poland’s historic enemies, the Germans over right here and the Russians over there.
Previous PiS campaigns have featured bogeys akin to Muslim migrants, queer and trans folks, Brussels technocrats and others allegedly bent on corrupting genuine Polish-Catholic mores. To win subsequent 12 months’s election, PiS has determined to roll out the ugly German once more.
Jaroslaw Kaczynski, the occasion’s chief, talks of “German-Russian plans to rule over Europe” and of the EU turning into a “Fourth German Reich.” He slanders his opposition as eager to make Poland an “appendage of Germany.” As although straight rebutting Sikorski in 2011, the present Polish international minister, Zbigniew Rau, just lately mentioned that “the EU needs not German leadership, but German self-restraint.”
The Germans, for his or her half, have — largely out of parochial absent-mindedness — lived all the way down to stereotype. Ignoring Sikorski’s plea, they haven’t included the Poles — or Balts or others — of their decision-making.
The worst occasion of their neglect was Nord Stream 2, a fuel pipeline constructed — after Russia’s first assaults on Ukraine in 2014, no much less — beneath the Baltic Sea from Russia to Germany. Running proper subsequent to Nord Stream 1, this link was supposed to produce low-cost Russian hydrocarbons to assist Germany’s vitality transition. The Germans had been additionally satisfied that doing extra enterprise with Russian President Vladimir Putin would preserve him meek.
By distinction, the Poles and different jap Europeans (together with the Ukrainians), acknowledged each Nord Stream pipelines as geopolitical schemes by Putin to make the connectors working by their very own international locations irrelevant, so he may blackmail or starve them at will. Worse, the entire undertaking appeared like yet one more separate Russo-German deal over their heads, the kind historical past has taught them to worry.
This 12 months, as Putin weaponized Russia’s vitality exports, the world discovered who was proper (the Poles) and fallacious (the Germans) in that argument. I’m not conscious of any German politician who’s explicitly apologized to Warsaw, Riga, Tallinn, Vilnius or Kyiv for the pipelines — or for all of the Kremlin coddling that went with them.
These jap capitals — whose international locations as soon as made up what the historian Timothy Snyder calls the “bloodlands” between Hitler and Stalin — at the moment are on the entrance line towards Putin’s assault on Ukraine and decency. The 4 inside the EU and NATO are main the Western alliance in calling out Putin’s lies and modeling the braveness to withstand.
Berlin, for its half, has merely fallen in line behind its jap EU companions. Its resolve got here late and infrequently seems wobbly. Leadership — by Germany as a rustic or Scholz as a chancellor — seems completely different.
There are two tragedies on this story. The first is that Kaczynski, PiS, and their populist ilk in different international locations are enjoying with fireplace. They’re besmirching European beliefs of reconciliation and wrecking desires of power in unity. Instead of asking for reparations for what Hitler did in World War II — that’s, as a substitute of stoking resentment — they need to be linking arms with all their European pals to defeat Putin.
The second tragedy is that the Germans are not any wiser. Thomas Mann might be delivering his grave. Europe is just not German, and no person needs that. Nor, nevertheless, is Germany any nearer to being genuinely European.
Germany won’t ever once more be the risk to Europe it as soon as was — as of late, Russia performs that half. But that’s hardly a excessive customary. Not solely the Poles, however all Europeans could be forgiven for feeling that they will’t stay with the Germans, however can’t stay with out them both.
This column doesn’t essentially mirror the opinion of the editorial board or Bloomberg LP and its homeowners.
Andreas Kluth is a Bloomberg Opinion columnist protecting European politics. A former editor in chief of Handelsblatt Global and a author for the Economist, he’s writer of “Hannibal and Me.”
More tales like this can be found on bloomberg.com/opinion
