Chain restaurants — these ubiquitous monuments to company consistency, from Applebee’s to Arby’s, Olive Garden to Pizza Hut — are most frequent in Kentucky, West Virginia and Alabama. They’re rarest in Vermont, Alaska and Hawaii. Maine, New York and D.C. additionally are inclined to have fewer chains.
The chain restaurant capital of the nation is the metro space round Anniston, Ala., dwelling to the Talladega Superspeedway. Nearly 3 in 5 restaurants there are chains.
Department of Data
and wondrous energy of the information that defines our world.
Read more.
Nestled in the southern reaches of Appalachia, off the interstate between Birmingham, Ala., and Atlanta, Anniston is accustomed to life as a nationwide punching bag. It has been named amongst the “most dangerous” and “fastest shrinking” cities and seems on lists of the worst locations to reside and the locations the place staff are most seemingly to get replaced by robots. In 2019, native reporter and creator Tim Lockette wrote a useful information for residents titled, “FIVE THINGS to know when Anniston lands on a ‘10 worst’ list again.”
Anniston lies in Calhoun County, which Trump received in 2020 with 73 p.c of the two-party vote, which excludes votes forged for third-party candidates. That makes it an exemplar of the Trump-chain restaurant nexus. In the Trumpiest fifth of the United States, counties the place Trump obtained not less than 63.3 p.c of the two-party vote in the previous presidential election, 37 p.c of the restaurants are chains. In the least Trumpy fifth, the place Trump obtained lower than 32.1 p.c of the vote, it’s 23 p.c.
There are exceptions. One of the chainiest cities in the nation is Waldorf, Md., a fast-growing, majority Black D.C. suburb in Charles County, which President Biden received with 71 p.c of the two-party vote. But it’s typically secure to imagine that the greater the Trump vote, the extra chain restaurants you’ll discover.
Ocean City, N.J., tops the record of least-chainy metros in America, which is dominated by vacationer hubs in locations like the Hawaiian island of Maui and Cape Cod in Massachusetts. Their ultra-chainy counterparts at each the metropolis and metro ranges sometimes look extra like Anniston: working-class cities, typically in Appalachia.
We outlined chains as restaurants with not less than 50 retailers with the similar identify nationwide, primarily based on Andris and Liang’s evaluation of a database of more than 700,000 restaurants from marketing-data agency Leads Deposit. That consists of virtually 400 companies, from heavyweights resembling Subway and Dunkin’ to specialists resembling HuHot Mongolian Grill and Morton’s steakhouse.
From there, we might weed out names resembling China Garden or Joe’s Pizza that have been frequent however not all owned by the similar of us.
Of the main cuisines, quick meals has the highest chain focus, whereas ethnic meals (other than pizza) are inclined to have the lowest. This could assist clarify why we frequently see fewer chain restaurants in areas with greater immigrant populations.
While the Trump vote correlates with the presence of chain restaurants, it clearly doesn’t clarify it. Our intestine advised us to have a look at inhabitants density. The density divide is the Ur-cleavage from which so many different fashionable American divisions movement. As locations get extra rural, training and revenue ranges fall and Trump help rises.
But chains don’t match completely into this worldview. Chain restaurant focus peaks in midsize cities and suburbs and tends to be decrease in each the most city and most rural areas. And at each density stage, the political divide stays: Rural areas received by Biden have fewer chains than rural areas received by Trump. Same goes for suburbs and main cities.
We examined different variables. Education appeared promising. Lower training ranges are inclined to deliver each extra chain restaurants and extra Republican votes. But even inside areas with related ranges of training, variations persevered. In the most educated Biden counties, about 26 p.c of restaurants have been chains. In the most educated Trump counties, 37 p.c have been — the similar as in the least educated Trump counties.
Something else was at work. One by one, we dominated out the prospects: It wasn’t age, both of individuals or of the neighborhood (as measured by the yr a typical dwelling was erected). It wasn’t focus of White inhabitants. It wasn’t revenue.
In the finish, we recognized one issue that transcended politics and defined the presence of chain restaurants all through the nation: driving. Specifically, the share of the workforce that drives to work every day.
The locations that drive the most are inclined to have the similar excessive share of chain restaurants no matter whether or not they voted for Trump or Biden. As automobile commuting decreases, chain restaurants lower at roughly the similar charge, regardless of which candidate most residents supported.
If the link between vehicles and chains transcends partisanship, why does it seem like Trump counties have extra chain restaurants? It’s not less than in half as a result of he received extra of the locations with the most automobile commuters!
About 83 p.c of staff commute by automobile nationally, however solely 80 p.c of oldsters in Biden counties achieve this, in contrast with 90 p.c of staff in Trump counties. The share of automobile commuters ranges from 55 p.c in the deep-blue New York City metro space to 96 p.c round shiny purple Decatur, Ala.
Alabama as a complete ranks second in automobile commuting (behind Mississippi) and third in chain restaurants (behind Kentucky and West Virginia) as individuals in the South are typically extra more likely to drive to work than of us in different areas.
We nonetheless aren’t certain why Trump received areas with extra automobile commuters — it may very well be linked to deeper cultural divides and hidden components that affect each driving and voting. The link between automobile commuting and chain restaurants appears clearer.
Andris, a Georgia Tech professor and director of its Friendly Cities Lab, says it’s all about highways. Highways and chains have been linked from the starting, when a burgeoning automobile tradition and a fast-metastasizing net of interstates gave rise to the roadside Howard Johnsons, one among America’s first nice chains.
Ever since, the chains have adopted the interstate lanes, creating a fast, transactional filling-station-for-the-human-body expertise that’s primarily the reverse of the distinctive environment and gastronomy accessible in the impartial restaurants that dot the nation’s waterfronts, ski cities and walkable, historic Main Streets.
Whether they’re commuting, working errands or road-tripping, individuals in car-dominated areas are inclined to crave the velocity and predictability of chains.
“The legacy of the highway seems to perpetuate chain restaurants,” Andris mentioned.
How do you do, fellow nerds? The Department of Data wants your data-driven questions. Let us know what you’re interested in: the relationship between driving and voting for Trump? The least traveled highways? The cities with the most parking tons? The math behind Zillow and Redfin’s home-value estimates? Just ask!
To get each query, reply and factoid in your inbox as quickly as we publish, join right here. If your query conjures up a column, we’ll ship a button and an official Department of Data ID card. This week, the button goes to Washington’s JR Pelkola, a childhood buddy who flagged the Georgia Tech evaluation lengthy earlier than the Department blinked into existence.
