Pete Arredondo and other law enforcement differ on what happened in Uvalde

Sign up for The Brief, our every day e-newsletter that retains readers on top of things on probably the most important Texas news.

In the 4 weeks since a gunman killed 19 kids and two academics at Robb Elementary School in Uvalde, law enforcement companies and state officers have given conflicting accounts of the police response, which has been criticized as a result of officers waited greater than an hour to take down the shooter.

At instances, officers have needed to appropriate, or fully retract, information that they had given the general public concerning the response to the taking pictures.

At the middle of the controversy is Pete Arredondo, chief of police for the Uvalde Consolidated Independent School District, who has been labeled as “incident commander” and criticized by state police for making essential errors. Earlier this month, Arredondo and his legal professional gave an exclusive and exhaustive interview to The Texas Tribune detailing what unfolded in the hallway on the day of the taking pictures and defending his position.

This week, new particulars emerged concerning the timeline of occasions as media shops together with the Tribune reported on surveillance video from the hallways that day and a transcript of officers’ physique cameras. In a public listening to to lawmakers Tuesday, Texas Department of Public Safety Director Steve McCraw offered extra particulars concerning the sequence of occasions and missed alternatives.

At least three investigations — from the U.S. Department of Justice, a Texas House investigative committee and the native district legal professional, Christina Mitchell Busbee — are wanting into the occasions that unfolded on May 24.

The narratives converge and diverge at completely different factors. Here is a breakdown of the important thing variations.

No try to open the door

In an interview with The Texas Tribune, Arredondo intimated that he was unable to cease the gunman in the adjoined lecture rooms 111 and 112 as a result of he couldn’t breach the doorways.

He advised the Tribune he tried to open room 111 and one other group of officers tried to open room 112. Believing the doorways had been locked, Arredondo known as for keys and extrication instruments to power the door open.

But safety footage from the hallways doesn’t seize any try by officers, together with Arredondo, to open the doorways.

The surveillance exhibits two teams of law enforcement officials approaching the doorways to the school rooms early on in the taking pictures — one group from the north of the hallway and the other, which incorporates Arredondo, from the south.

As every group approaches, the shooter opens fireplace, grazing two of the officers coming from the north and inflicting each teams to retreat again to their ends of the hallways.

After that, these officers stay in place for the remainder of the standoff, by no means firing a shot.

Although the footage exhibits no try by him to open the door, Arredondo advised the Tribune he believed the doorways to be locked. Some law enforcement officers at the moment are skeptical that the doorways had been ever locked as a result of the gunman was capable of stroll in and out of the classroom at the beginning of the taking pictures.

On Tuesday, McCraw advised lawmakers that a while earlier than the taking pictures, one of many academics who taught in the conjoined lecture rooms the place the taking pictures happened had advised the college’s administration that doorways to the classroom wouldn’t lock. McCraw additionally mentioned that the classroom doorways couldn’t have been locked from the within, indicating they might have been open if officers had tried to enter the room.

At 12:11 p.m. almost 40 minutes after the taking pictures started, Arredondo known as for a grasp key that might enable him to unlock classroom doorways, based on the transcript. It took about six minutes for a set of keys to reach, and Arredondo started testing them on a unique classroom door, based on the transcript and Arredondo’s recollection.

Arredondo mentioned the primary key ring he was introduced didn’t include a grasp key. He mentioned he was introduced a second key ring with between 20 and 30 keys, and none of these labored both.

Both accounts say that one other group, which included Border Patrol brokers, lastly discovered a grasp key that might unlock the room.

That group inserted the important thing into room 111 and entered the room at 12:50 p.m. A flurry of gunshots might be heard in the video, and then the staff exits the room and signifies the gunman is lifeless.

Timeline of occasions

Arredondo mentioned he believed he was one of many first officers on the scene and requested police dispatch for tactical gear, snipers, keys and an extrication instrument to assist officers reply to a gunman who had barricaded himself inside a classroom and had a high-powered rifle.

A law enforcement timeline offered to the Tribune this week has Arredondo’s name for these objects at 11:40 a.m.

Arredondo mentioned the extrication instruments, which may have helped officers pry open the classroom doorways, by no means reached him in the hallway. The law enforcement timeline exhibits {that a} Halligan bar, an ax-like forcible-entry instrument utilized by firefighters, was on the scene inside the first minutes of the law enforcement response.

It was not introduced into the college till an hour after the primary officers entered the constructing. Authorities didn’t use it and as an alternative waited for keys. It is unclear why.

Arredondo additionally advised the Tribune officers held off on coming into the school rooms for thus lengthy as a result of they had been outgunned by the shooter and didn’t have the right tools to open the door and take the shooter down.

McCraw mentioned Tuesday that officers with rifles arrived inside minutes of the taking pictures’s begin and may have aided an entry into the room.

The gunman entered the college at 11:33 a.m. By midday, based on the law enforcement timeline, officers had rifles, a Halligan and at the very least one ballistic protect.

Over the course of the standoff with the gunman, officers would acquire entry to 4 ballistic shields earlier than lastly coming into the room the place the gunman was and taking pictures him at 12:50 p.m.

The first ballistic protect arrived 58 minutes earlier than then. The final one arrived half-hour earlier than.

It is unclear why officers didn’t use the ballistic shields to have interaction the shooter earlier.

Radios

One of Arredondo’s most fateful selections was made inside seconds of arriving on the scene, when he opted to depart his radios behind earlier than speeding into the college. He advised the Tribune that he believed he was the primary officer on the scene and needed each fingers free in order that he may fireplace on the gunman rapidly and precisely if he encountered him.

If he’d carried the radios, they might have been an encumbrance to his fast response to the taking pictures, Arredondo mentioned, as a result of one would fall off his belt throughout a future and the other had a whiplike antenna that might have slowed him down.

That resolution left him with no direct communication to other officers responding to the scene. Instead, Arredondo used his cellphone to make calls to police dispatch and talk what he was seeing.

Arredondo advised the Tribune he didn’t keep in mind requesting a police radio as soon as he was in the hallway.

But the transcripts of the timeline offered to the Tribune present Arredondo asking for a radio: “I need you to bring a radio for me,” Arredondo advised dispatch.

Confusion about who was in cost

DPS officers have described Arredondo because the scene’s incident commander and mentioned he made the decision to face down and deal with the scenario as a “barricaded suspect” reasonably than a hostage scenario.

Arredondo advised the Tribune he by no means thought of himself the incident commander in cost of the response to the taking pictures and didn’t subject any orders to face down.

But some officers on the scene appeared to suppose Arredondo was in cost. At 11:50 a.m., one officer mentioned, “The chief is in charge,” based on a transcript of a physique digicam.

By 12:01 p.m., a DPS officer began suggesting that the scenario required officers to enter the classroom.

“It sounds like a hostage rescue situation,” the DPS officer mentioned. “Sounds like a UC [undercover] rescue. They should probably go in.”

A police officer — it’s not clear whether or not from the town or college district — then mentioned, “Don’t you think we should have a supervisor approve that?”

“He’s not my supervisor,” the DPS agent countered earlier than leaving the hallway to clear other rooms of kids.

Arredondo additionally gave the impression to be issuing orders resembling directing officers to evacuate college students from other lecture rooms. Arredondo has mentioned he was appearing as one other first responder in trying to speak with other officers in the hallway, and believed another person was in cost of supervising the response.

The New York Times reported that when a bunch of officers from completely different companies, together with Border Patrol, breached the room to kill the gunman, they waved off somebody in their earpiece telling them to not enter the room and believed they had been appearing on their very own initiative. George E. Hyde, Arredondo’s lawyer, mentioned that individual was not his shopper and the incident exhibits that somebody other than Arredondo was giving orders on the scene.

Waiting greater than an hour to enter the classroom

Both accounts are constant that law enforcement officers waited greater than an hour earlier than breaching the room and killing the gunman.

In Arredondo’s account, the wait was as a result of officers had been ready for extrication instruments or keys to open the door to the room the place the gunman was. Arredondo believed the door to be locked, and whereas police waited for a key to return, they targeted on evacuating kids in surrounding rooms as a result of the shooter was nonetheless sporadically taking pictures his weapon with bullets that might pierce by partitions.

In the law enforcement timeline offered to the Tribune, it’s unclear why police didn’t breach the room. At completely different factors through the wait of greater than an hour, they acquire entry to extrication instruments, ballistic shields, rifles and keys. But it nonetheless takes till 12:50 p.m. for them to breach the room and kill the gunman.

An absence of a transparent incident commander seems to decelerate the response in the law enforcement timeline, with some officers believing they need to breach the room and others believing they wanted supervisory approval earlier than doing so.

Disclosure: The New York Times has been a monetary supporter of The Texas Tribune, a nonprofit, nonpartisan news group that’s funded in half by donations from members, foundations and company sponsors. Financial supporters play no position in the Tribune’s journalism. Find a whole list of them here.

Join us Sept. 22-24 in individual in downtown Austin for The Texas Tribune Festival and expertise 100+ dialog occasions that includes large names you realize and others you must from the worlds of politics, public coverage, the media and tech — all curated by The Texas Tribune’s award-winning journalists. Buy tickets.